Manufacturing consent

Published by
Clint Azzopardi Flores

Today I wasn’t quite sure what I was going to write. It’s time, though, for someone to offer a bit of perspective. The way certain people construct arguments has become increasingly divorced from any real analytical examination. Some economic and political arguments being put forward simply don’t hold water, even though the people making them are capable of far more sophisticated analysis.

The overpopulation and cheap labour narrative, framed under Chomsky’s theory

However, I was still thinking about narratives being created, amplified, and repeated as a form of manufacturing consent. That led me back to Chomsky. Manufacturing consent doesn’t require a conspiracy or coordinated effort. It’s about the filters through which information passes before reaching the public. Over time, certain assumptions become common sense, not because they have been tested against facts, but because they are repeated so often, they shape how people think. It’s now clear that what is said, especially non-factual narratives, has been filtered and amplified to shape the public’s understanding of the issues.

Let us take the overpopulation argument that has been building for the past few years. Several politicians of the Nationalist Party, and subsequently supporters and non-supporters, believe the Maltese economy grew simply because the government imported labour from other countries, mostly third-country nationals (TCNs), rather than because employers needed to fill vacancies. A few weeks ago, they called them cheap labour. Now they use the terms overpopulation and cheap labour interchangeably.

Indeed, TCNs contributed to our economy, serviced our hospitals, and cleaned our hotels, streets, and restaurants. They still contribute and will continue to do so. TCNs came to Malta because there was work. What concerns me is the prominence with which mass media reported what the Nationalist Party, or some actors within it, said over the years regarding TCNs. Through repetition and visibility, certain arguments gained legitimacy long before sufficient scrutiny. This is where Chomsky’s framework is relevant, not because the media dictate opinions, but because they influence which perspectives dominate public political discourse, even unknowingly.

I am not saying we did not need to plan better and accelerate infrastructure projects at the same pace our economy grew. However, it has often been reported that our planning disorder, symptomatic of every government, was the fault of others who came here to serve us and our economy. That is unfair, amounts to scapegoating, and is politically convenient. The argument of overpopulation is just one example. This does not happen only within the media but also within broader institutional frameworks.

Topics that offer a different perspective after filtering

Such mechanisms operate by maintaining passive obedience, sometimes without overt coercion. Acceptable debate on any topic in Malta, whether in favour of, against, or neutral towards any political party, is often limited by the fostering of intense arguments within obtuse boundaries. This gives citizens and supporters the impression of a wider choice of perspectives while restricting discussion to reinforce conformity around certain assumptions. I still try to approach these debates independently and resist conforming to prevailing narratives.

Now that Budget 2027 has been presented, our focus will shift to other themes. These themes will again be narrowed and filtered by the media, shaping the boundaries of debate and influencing which narratives gain prominence. It is a kind of self-censorship embedded within broader communication systems. Similar filtering mechanisms can also emerge within broader European reporting and communication frameworks. To counter such a system requires more than individual moral courage. It requires a willingness to challenge the assumptions guiding public discourse. Given that the PL in government, which I am part of, now acknowledges it needs to change policy because it has taken note of what people want, part of what people demand has also been shaped by the media, augmented by social media, through the filtering and amplification of messages that contribute to manufacturing consent.

Regulating the markets and explaining the meaning of productivity measures

As much as I agree with the Finance Minister that something should have been done before, especially since I have been writing the same things for five years about controlling how we engage additional labour – and this is where filtering must have been applied – I believe the narrative framed by the Nationalist Party in the past and now is neither proportionate nor factual. This is especially true of the suggestion that the economy grows simply because we import additional labour.

Indeed, another narrative recently reinforced concerns productivity. Here, once again, we see the manufacture of consent by many who say we need to become more productive and shed labour. We can use the term productivity, but those proposing it must explain how they measure it, across which sectors, and for whose benefit we must become more productive. Too often, productivity is presented as a simple equation, meaning fewer workers, more machinery, higher output. In truth, reality is far more complex.

Productivity gains differ across sectors and depend on investment cycles, technology adoption, skills, and market conditions, especially economic sentiment, which the Nationalist Party tried to undermine over the past year. It is not a slogan to be repeated but an economic concept to be understood. I have already asked them which sectors they will clean up if they are in government. And as usual, there was no reply.

If we are to improve policymaking, we must first improve the quality of the arguments in Parliament, upon which policy is shaped, influenced and built. And if we are to have a healthier public debate, we must be willing to question not only the conclusions presented to us, but also the assumptions that led us there at the outset.

Clint Azzopardi Flores

Clint Azzopardi Flores is an economist & former PSC Ambassador.

Recent Posts

Saving Malta’s Honeybee: Can Comino secure the future of the island’s native bee?

Malta is home to Apis mellifera ruttneri, an endemic subspecies of the Western honeybee that…

2 minutes ago

Why Europe should invest in Jordan

A strategic partnership for shared prosperity and a more stable Middle East Dubravka Šuica  &…

2 hours ago

Transforming an economic growth model demands patience, trust, and a holistic approach

There is now a rare consensus. Our current economic growth model has reached an inflection…

2 hours ago

Malta’s maritime industry contributes €1 billion to the economy, new study finds

Malta Maritime Forum launches second economic study of the Maltese maritime sector The maritime industry…

17 hours ago

Free business course for people with disabilities opens with Global Entrepreneurship Week workshop

FPEI’s University of Malta-accredited EntrAbility programme includes an online business idea workshop on Friday, 20…

18 hours ago

APS Bank cyclists raise €11,300 for Provident Fund in Sicily challenge

Four APS Bank colleagues have raised €11,300 for the APS Provident Fund after completing a…

18 hours ago